There’s something about cookies and cream that feels instantly familiar. It’s nostalgic but still indulgent. The contrast of dark chocolate cookie crumbs and sweet vanilla cream just works every single time. If I see anything labeled cookies and cream, I will probably buy it. Ice cream, cake, protein bar, yogurt… it doesn’t matter. So turning that flavor into a brown butter cookie felt inevitable. It’s comfort layered with depth, the classic flavor you grew up loving, upgraded with that warm, nutty bakery finish. Check out how to brown butter blog post, esepcially if this is your first time making brown butter.
The foundation. Browning the butter removes excess water and toasts the milk solids, creating a deep, nutty flavor that balances the sweetness of the cookies and cream pieces. Always use a light-colored saucepan so you can see when it turns golden, not burnt.
Your bakery-level upgrade. Milk powder intensifies the brown butter flavor by adding extra toasted milk solids without changing the texture. It creates a richer, warmer cookie with more depth.
If you skip it, the cookies will still be delicious. They just won’t have quite the same layered nuttiness.
Adds moisture and chew. The molasses in brown sugar keeps the centers soft and enhances the caramel notes from the brown butter.
Adds structure and slight crispness around the edges. The smaller ratio compared to brown sugar ensures these stay chewy, not crunchy.
The extra yolk is key. It adds richness and tenderness while helping the cookies stay thick and plush in the center.
Room temperature eggs blend more smoothly into warm brown butter.
Vanilla rounds out the chocolate and cream flavors and complements the toasted butter. Don’t skimp here. This is part of what makes them taste bakery-level instead of flat.
Structure and stability. Be sure to spoon and level your flour to avoid dry cookies. Too much flour makes them cakey instead of chewy.
Softness insurance. Cornstarch limits gluten development and keeps the centers tender and thick.
Balances sweetness and enhances the chocolate. Without salt, cookies taste one-dimensional.
Helps cookies spread slightly and creates chew.
Adds lift so the centers stay puffed instead of flat.
Place butter in a light-colored saucepan over medium heat.
Melt completely, then continue cooking.
The butter will:
When it smells nutty and turns amber, remove from heat immediately.
Stir in the milk powder and transfer to a mixing bowl.
Cool 10–15 minutes.
Whisk the sugars into the warm butter until glossy and fully combined.
It will look slightly grainy, that’s normal.
Add egg, egg yolk, and vanilla.
Whisk until smooth and thick.
In a separate bowl whisk together:
Fold dry ingredients into wet just until mostly combined.
Leave visible flour streaks.
Add chopped cookies and gently mix until no dry flour remains.
Cover and chill 30 to 60 minutes.
This hydrates the flour and prevents spreading.
Preheat oven to 350°F
Scoop dough balls and space 2 inches apart.
Press extra cookie pieces on top.
Bake 10 to 11 minutes
Edges = lightly golden
Centers = soft and puffed
Cool 5 minutes on the pan, then transfer to rack.
They will look underbaked.
They finish setting as they cool.
Room temperature
Airtight container up to 3 days
Add a small piece of bread to keep soft
Refrigerator
Not recommended. Chills the butter flavor and firms the crumb.
Freeze baked cookies
Up to 2 months
Thaw or warm at 300°F
Freeze dough
Freeze scooped balls and bake from frozen
Add 1–2 minutes bake time
Hydrates flour and solidifies butter so cookies stay thick instead of spreading flat.
Yes. Add 1 TBSP milk to the batter instead. Flavor will be slightly less nutty.
The centers finish cooking from residual heat. This keeps them soft for days.
Yes, but double stuffed gives better cream pockets.
It removes water and concentrates flavor, preventing bland sweetness.
Dough likely wasn’t chilled long enough or butter was too hot when eggs were added.
You want golden, not burnt. Think toasted hazelnut, not coffee ash.
**Milk Powder
Milk powder deepens the brown butter flavor, giving it that bakery-style, toasted richness. It’s usually found in the baking aisle near evaporated milk or in the international foods section.
Think of it as a flavor amplifier, not a requirement.
Room temperature
Airtight container up to 3 days
Add a small piece of bread to keep soft
Refrigerator
Not recommended. Chills the butter flavor and firms the crumb.
Freeze baked cookies
Up to 2 months
Thaw or warm at 300°F
Freeze dough
Freeze scooped balls and bake from frozen
Add 1–2 minutes bake time
I’m so grateful you’re here! Have a look around at some of my favourite recipes and stay a while.
Get a fresh delivery of only the goods delivered to your inbox.
Leave a comment